TL;DR
The 74 published an opinion piece arguing that educators should be able to test AI in their work while districts set rules for student use. The article draws on ASU Prep’s pilots to show how hands-on evaluation can reveal benefits and risks, while stressing that trials need privacy, security and quality safeguards.
The 74 has published an opinion piece arguing that schools should let teachers and other staff test artificial intelligence tools in their own work while districts decide what student use should be allowed. Drawing on ASU Prep’s experiments, the article says practical trials can help educators identify both potential benefits and risks that may be missed when policies are developed without classroom experience.
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
The article’s central argument is that educators need direct experience with AI to teach students how to use it critically. It distinguishes staff experimentation from unrestricted student access: the author supports limited, monitored pilots, not an unfiltered embrace of the technology. The piece says schools should assess how a tool affects learning, privacy and interaction before expanding its use.
At ASU Prep, a network of physical, digital and hybrid schools, staff were invited to suggest internal problems AI might help address. A cross-functional Strategic Solutions Team used the technology to organize curriculum documents, calendars and testing schedules into a planning resource. The resulting guides lay out skill sequences and common points of student difficulty, giving teachers, instructional coaches and school leaders a shared reference for identifying gaps and planning support.
The article reports that in one year ASU Prep reviewed 22 staff proposals, put six into use and evaluated more than 10 commercial AI tools with employees. It says the volume of requests exceeded the team’s capacity. The organization is creating departmental AI task forces, alongside a central review process intended to address privacy, security and quality.
How Staff Trials Could Shape School Policy
The argument matters because school leaders face a practical challenge: they must set boundaries for a fast-changing technology while many educators are still learning what it can and cannot do. The opinion piece contends that staff experience can inform decisions about student access, rather than leaving policy to abstract predictions or blanket restrictions.
Testing also brings tradeoffs into view. The article’s proposed three-part test asks whether an AI use makes work easier, improves it, and what it might weaken or damage. A tool could help organize instruction, for example, while an AI-assisted assignment could reduce the intellectual effort students are meant to practice. Personalized feedback could help learners, but overreliance on automated responses could displace human interaction. These are the author’s concerns and analysis, not findings from a reported controlled study.
For students, the broader implication is that AI literacy involves more than prompt-writing or a list of prohibited behaviors. The piece says students should learn to question whether an output is accurate, what assumptions it contains, who created the tool and whether they are using it to extend their thinking or replace it. Educators familiar with the tools may be better positioned to guide those discussions.
Products Worth Considering

BowFlex Results Series 552 SelectTech Adjustable Dumbbell

Hyperice Hypervolt 3 Percussion Massage Gun with Heated Head and Carry Case

Garmin Forerunner 55 GPS Running Watch, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
District Restrictions and ASU Prep’s Pilot
The article opens by describing restrictions in two large U.S. school districts. It says New York City imposed a one-year moratorium on generative AI for preschool through eighth grade, while Los Angeles blocked student access on district devices. The source does not provide the dates of those decisions, and the piece does not present them as the only possible policy response.
It also places school policy within a wider debate over the pace of AI development. The author contrasts the existing infrastructure on which generative AI arrived with earlier technologies that required new systems to be built. The article cites a rise in AI math performance, from fewer than one in 14 challenging high-school competition problems solved by leading systems in 2021 to a gold-medal score by an AI model at the International Mathematical Olympiad four years later. Those figures are presented as context for the author’s view that capabilities are developing quickly; they do not by themselves establish what AI tools will do in schools.
ASU Prep’s approach, as described in the opinion piece, pairs local experimentation with central oversight. The article also cites Khan World School, an online honors high school operated by ASU Prep, where students may use AI in research before presenting and defending their positions in live discussions. The author presents that model as an example of AI supporting student thinking without replacing classroom dialogue.
“You cannot govern what you have not used.”
— The opinion article’s author
Limits of the Evidence and Policy
The source is an opinion article, and it does not report a formal study measuring whether ASU Prep’s AI tools improved student achievement, reduced staff workload or produced other outcomes. It describes how the organization used the tools and how it plans to review them, but does not provide evaluation results or detailed measures of success.
It is also unclear from the source when the cited district restrictions took effect, whether they have since changed, and what specific access rules apply in each district. The article does not specify the safeguards, age limits or approval standards that should govern every school pilot. It argues for monitored trials, while leaving the design of those rules to schools and districts.
More broadly, the article does not settle how much AI use is appropriate for different ages, subjects or assignments. Outcomes may vary by tool and classroom setting. Its recommendation is to learn through limited testing, not a claim that a single approach will work for all schools.
ASU Prep’s Next Review Steps
According to the article, ASU Prep is creating departmental AI task forces so employees closer to particular areas of work can identify and test possible uses. A central review process is also planned to examine privacy, security and quality. The source does not give a timetable for those task forces or report results from their work.
The article recommends that schools support limited pilots involving educators and operations staff, monitor data security, set age-appropriate expectations, and review what a tool strengthens or diminishes. Those steps would let schools revise policies as tools and experience change. No new district policy or broader regulatory decision is announced in the source; the next developments to watch are the outcomes of school pilots and how districts translate them into rules for staff and students.
Key Questions
What does the opinion piece recommend schools do?
It argues that schools should allow educators and staff to test AI in limited, monitored pilots while districts decide what student use should involve. It does not recommend unrestricted access.
What did ASU Prep use AI for?
The article says ASU Prep used AI to combine curriculum documents, calendars and testing schedules into instructional planning guides. It reports reviewing 22 staff ideas, putting six into use and evaluating more than 10 commercial tools with employees over one year.
What risks does the article identify?
It raises concerns about sensitive student data, weaker opportunities for productive intellectual effort and overreliance on automated feedback at the expense of human interaction. These are risks identified by the author, not reported outcomes of a formal evaluation.
Does the piece say students should use AI without restrictions?
No. The author calls for age-appropriate expectations, data-security monitoring and limited pilots. The argument is that educators should gain experience with AI so they can help students use it critically.
What remains unknown about ASU Prep’s results?
The source does not provide measured effects on student learning, staff workload or other outcomes, nor does it give a timeline for the new departmental task forces. It also does not set out one policy suitable for every school or age group.
Source: rss
